mueller41_ALBERTO PIZZOLIAFP via Getty Images_meloni

Politics

Как определить фашиста?

Nov 7, 2022 Jan-Werner Mueller

ПРИНСТОН – Прошло почти ровно сто лет после «Марша на Рим» фашистского лидера Бенито Муссолини и его назначения премьер-министром Италии, и теперь итальянским премьер-министром стала Джорджа Мелони – политик, чья партия ведёт происхождение от этих изначальных фашистов. Неужели мы стали свидетелями возвращения фашизма (в более скромной версии) – политического явления, которое после 1922 года вышло далеко за пределы Италии?

Нет ничего плохого в том, чтобы задавать вопросы, но, если слишком вольно разбрасываться «ф-словом», тогда лидерам крайне правых будет проще заявлять, что их критики всё преувеличивают, в том числе масштабы угрозы демократии. Совершенно предсказуемо Мелони всеми силами старалась дистанцироваться от фашизма в своей первой речи в парламенте в качестве премьера.

И всё же, рассматривая проблему фашизма сегодня, нужно помнить, что он проходит через разные фазы. Сейчас в Европе и на американском континенте нет фашистских режимов, но точно есть партии, в том числе правящие, которые постепенно могут сдвинуться в сторону фашизма.

To continue reading, register now.

Subscribe now for unlimited access to everything PS has to offer.

As a registered user, you can enjoy more PS content every month – for free.

Already have an account? Log in

PS Events: What Economics is Missing

Our latest event, What Economics is Missing, is now live.

Click the link below for opening remarks from Dani Rodrik, followed by a discussion among Ashwini Deshpande, Raquel Fernández, Minouche Shafik, and Vera Songwe on how to achieve inclusivity in economics.

Watch Now

One Hundred Years of Fascism
BIPs/Getty Images and Tayfun Coskun/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

Longer Reads 7

One Hundred Years of Fascism

Jason Stanley marks the centennial of Mussolini’s March on Rome by explaining the ideology’s staying power.
Giorgia Meloni’s Balancing Act
Antonio Masiello/Getty Images

Politics 0

Giorgia Meloni’s Balancing Act

Federico Fubini wonders how long Italy’s far-right prime minister can reconcile moderate policies with her voters’ demands.
January 6 and the Possessive White Male
ROBERTO SCHMIDTAFP via Getty Images

Culture 5

January 6 and the Possessive White Male

Jan-Werner Mueller sees in the insurrectionists’ mindset and behavior resentment over the loss of illegitimate privilege.

new comment has been posted. new comments have been posted.

0 Comments on this paragraph, 3 Comments on this article

Curtis Carpenter Nov 13, 2022

Perhaps it's important to differentiate between "applied fascism" and the spirit of it, never mind how it's made. And in spirit, I'm reminded of the famous dialog about words between Alice and Humpty Dumpty in Through the Looking Glass:

"When I use a word," Humpty Dumpty said, in rather a scornful tone, "it means just what I choose it to mean—neither more nor less." "The question is," said Alice, "whether you can make words mean so many different things." "The question is," said Humpty Dumpty, "which is to be master—that's all."
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
Mirek Fatyga Nov 8, 2022

I am not sure that I agree with the last paragraph: "it is a failure of political judgment to conflate todays far right with Fascism".

Fascism is a political method of ruling societies through incitement of emotion. Incitement of emotion is accomplished through propaganda. This is why Fascist regimes see the press and independent thinkers as their prime opponents.

The opposite of Fascism is Democracy which is often conflated with elections. While elections are a necessary condition for democracy, they are not sufficient. Democracy can only be preserved if political elites maintain the commitment to stop demagogues who want to rule through incitement of public emotion. The Fascist danger in the US and Europe is that a significant fraction of political elites abandoned this commitment and elected to succumb to demagoguery in the interest of pursuit of power.

Fascism is dangerous because it tends to work. Humans are not particularly rational. Owing to our evolutionary roots, we are primary emotional creatures and logical reasoning comes to us hard. Therefore, Democracy requires constant love and attention, strong commitment to quality education and robust mechanisms to suppress political incitement of emotion. Once any of these mechanisms break, Fascism, not Democracy is a default solution. If the society comes under stress due to circumstances, Fascism becomes even more likely. The most powerful human emotion is fear. It is easy to induce and exploit great fear when there is plenty of fear to go around already.

Fascism has many manifestations. Some of these manifestations just devastate their own societies. If Fascism emerges in the country which has a potential for technological and military power, it often leads to devastating wars. Conflating Fascism just with Hitler and Mussolini was a faithful mistake after WW2. This mistake is understandable as the survivors of WW2 wanted to put the war behind them and move on to a better life. In actual reality, however, Fascism was popular in Europe between the wars, in fact quite fashionable. Fascist trends were also strong in the United States. It could be said that the US ended up as the arsenal of Democracy due to a random act of the Empire of Japan which caused the US to enter the war against the axis powers. The victory of "realism" over "idealism" and an accommodation with a victorious Nazi Germany in Europe was a perfectly plausible outcome in my opinion. Argentina is an example of what could have happened.

As a result of the failure to fully account for Fascism in the interwar period, we are inventing now new euphemisms to call Fascism something else because we compare present day Fascism with German concentration camps. Hitler was just one endpoint of Fascism which was particularly destructive because he captured a society with high potential for scientific, technological and military excellence. He also captured a society which was already primed for resentment.

The present day incarnation of Fascism is now devastating Ukraine with a largest land war in Europe since WW2. Just like 100 years ago Moscow hosted Communist International (Red Fascism), today it is hosting Fascist international (Brown Fascism) radiating into Western Europe. We do not have to conflate anything any more, Fascism is upon us again because of generational amnesia. Fortunately, it does not yet have a full blown counterpart in Western Europe, but this may come as well. Fascist trends are clearly visible there and the widening war is imposing stress on societies.

Fascism is a political method that is as simple as A-B-C. A: find a scapegoat; B-induce fear and hatred of B through propaganda; C- present yourself as a savior. If you look at the western world today, Fascism is attempting a breakout everywhere. Don't belittle this breakout with platitudes that it is not "quite as bad yet". It is bad already and in the era of nuclear weapons consequences can be many fold more catastrophic than consequences of WW2.
- Kathleen McMullen Nov 14, 2022
  
  Fascism represses emotions in particular empathy, the ability to understand and share the feelings of another; even a stranger or someone from a different background. It represses compassion and kindness and insists on indifference to the suffering of others. Anger, especially about injustice, is another emotion that fascists would seek to suppress in favour of obedience and passivity. Where civil society is well established and developed fascism is going to have a hard time persuading citizens to repress their opinions about fairness, justice and being a good neighbour.
  A new reply to this comment has been posted.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.

https://prosyn.org/piiRbmNru

Как определить фашиста?

PS Events: What Economics is Missing

One Hundred Years of Fascism

Giorgia Meloni’s Balancing Act

January 6 and the Possessive White Male

New Comment

Contact us

Log in/Register

Как определить фашиста?

PS Events: What Economics is Missing

Edit Newsletter Preferences

Set up Notification